The Money Stories Your Clients Bring to the Table (and the Ones You Bring Too)

A holiday table set for a family dinner, where many of our earliest beliefs about money are formed.

By the second week of December, the year-end meetings start to sound familiar.

One client wants to review her distributions, but she keeps circling back to whether she should really spend money on the family trip. Another defers every question to her husband, even the ones about her own inherited money. A third has run the numbers on helping with the grandkids' tuition four different ways, and every version puts her own goals last.

None of them came in to talk about their family money habits. And somehow, part of the meeting always circles back to that.

Your own holiday gatherings can be similar. We sit at the same tables, hear the same phrases, and slip back into the same roles we had at twelve. A week later, those stories walk into your office and sit down across from you.

Where our beliefs about money come from

Most beliefs about money form long before we have any say in them. We absorb them from the way a parent sighed at the grocery bill, the argument we overheard about the car payment, the grandparent who saved every twist tie, and the relative everyone (kind of) quietly judged for spending too much.

By the time someone becomes a client, those messages rarely sound like beliefs. They sound like common sense:

  • Don't spend it on yourself.

  • Someone else handles the money in this family.

  • The kids come first.

  • Never let anyone know how much you have.

Psychologist Dr. Brad Klontz calls these money scripts: unconscious beliefs that keep shaping financial decisions throughout life. They often show up as a feeling instead of a sentence. Guilt when a purchase fits comfortably inside the plan. Relief when someone else decides. A tight chest when the conversation turns to "What do you want?"

The stories across the table

Think about those three clients again.

The one who feels guilty spending may have grown up in a house where every purchase needed a defense. Her plan says yes. Her story still says no.

The one who defers to her spouse may have learned early that money talk belonged to someone else. Her silence is not a lack of intelligence or interest. It is a role she was handed.

The one who always puts the kids first may be living out a definition of good parenting she absorbed decades ago, one where her own needs never quite make the list.

As advisors, we are trained to respond to the numbers. Run another scenario. Show the projection again. Sometimes that helps. Often the hesitation has nothing to do with the math, and another chart only adds pressure.

Noticing the story doesn't mean becoming your client's therapist. It means asking one more question before you reach for the next slide: "When you picture spending this, what comes up for you?" Sometimes the answer is a practical concern. Sometimes it is a parent's voice.

The stories on your side of the table

Here is the part we talk about less. You carry inherited money stories too.

They show up in what you charge, how much you over-deliver, and how responsible you feel for outcomes you can't control. Maybe you discount your fee before anyone asks. Maybe you send the extra analysis at 9:00 p.m. because a good advisor always goes above and beyond. Maybe a client's market loss sits in your stomach for a week, as if you were supposed to hold the market up yourself.

I know those patterns well. For years I was The Responsible One in every room: with clients, with my team, and at home. It looked like excellent service. Underneath, some of it was an old rule I had never examined: if someone is worried, it's my job to fix it.

When our stories stay unnamed, they shape the meeting without our permission. The discomfort you feel about a client's choice might be her story. It might also be yours.

Remember and choose

Each November, we lean into the idea of remembering. The point is not to live in the past. It is to notice what we carried out of it.

A few questions to bring into your year-end meetings, and into a quiet half hour of your own:

  • What did money mean in the house I grew up in?

  • Which money message do I still hear when I set my fees or say yes to extra work?

  • When a client's choice makes me uncomfortable, is that her story or mine?

  • What would I tell a client who carried the story I carry?

You don't need to resolve every answer. Remembering is enough for now. Once a story has a name, it has less power to make the decision for you.

A framework for both sides of the table

This is the core idea behind Money Is a Mirror. Our relationship with money reflects the stories we absorbed long before we had a say in them. The book gives you a way to look at those stories with curiosity instead of judgment, first in your own life and then in the conversations you have with clients.

It also makes a meaningful holiday gift. For the client who always puts herself last, the colleague who carries everyone, or the advisor friend who will recognize herself on every page, it says: I see you, and there is more freedom available than you might think.

Order Money Is a Mirror for yourself, a client, or a colleague this season. Gifting to a whole client list? Ask about bulk orders.

Next
Next

What If a Successful Practice Isn't the Point?